Mivy James has been an IT professional for over 20 years. Rptr. Rptr. 313, 1.5) dealt with contracts for professional and technical services. (a)(2).). Finding that none of Caltrans's policy arguments favoring reconsideration of Riley has substantial merit, we therefore decline to overrule or disapprove Riley and its progeny. 4th 603] and limits pertaining to the use of such funds. h]k0. (Id. 3d 171, 177, this court stated: "We are very mindful that article XXXIV [concerning local elections on low-rent housing projects] is a direct expression of the People who, alone, have the power to adopt or change the Constitution [citation], and that the judiciary, rather than the Legislature, is principally charged with its construction. 875, 583 P.2d 729]; Los Angeles Met. There is nothing in Riley to suggest that personnel shortages, earthquakes, economic efficiencies, new state functions, higher skills, etc., would not be within the meaning of this exception. On the one hand, the plaintiff relied on the presumption of constitutionality to argue for a deferential standard, while its opponents argued the question was one of statutory interpretation which the court should consider de novo. (1985) 40 Cal. 2d 575, 579-582 [184 P.2d 505]; Stockburger v. Riley (1937) 21 Cal. In Caltrans's view, the rules these cases announced are unsupported by the bare language of the civil service mandate and constitute further judicial legislation. (Riley, supra, 9 Cal.2d at p. 135; accord, Burum v. State Compensation Ins. (Professional Engineers, supra, 13 Cal.App.4th at p. (e) [plans and specifications for projects to comply with Caltrans's standards for state transportation projects].) [Citations.] 2d 176], Caltrans sought to enter into contracts with private firms to maintain roadside rest areas. 2d 552]; accord, Fowler v. Howell (1996) 42 Cal. opn., ante, at p. "Courts do not sit as super-legislatures to determine the wisdom, desirability or propriety of statutes enacted by the Legislature. of Kennedy, J.). Leaders elected by PECG's 13,000 members establish PECG's policies. The Majority Err by Approving the Trial Court's Reliance on the Truth of its Own 1990 Findings to Reject the Legislature's Subsequent Factual Findings. 4th 580] with previous legislative findings regarding the need for additional contracting flexibility to ensure timely and cost-effective project delivery, fn. Those objections are off the mark. Since the trial court erred in its determination that Chapter 433 was unconstitutional, the entire basis upon which it refused to modify or dissolve the injunction must be reversed. A title authority indicates a proficiency in that field greater than what is required for Civil Engineering licensure. App. par. 3d 692, 699 [170 Cal. Rptr. Before today the rules mandating judicial deference to legislative enactments were firmly established. [] Such is not the case. Dennis F. Moss, Gary P. Reynolds, Harry J. Gibbons, Sam A. McCall, Jr., Neil Robertson, Williams, Romanski, Polverari & Skelton and Anthony M. Santana as Amici Curiae on behalf of Plaintiffs and Respondents. 461-462; see also Amador Valley Joint Union High Sch. J Y2UETU2+]g0Zb. [Citation.] Of course, nothing in this opinion would prevent Caltrans from seeking modification of the 1990 injunction based on a showing that particular contracts are justified because state workers cannot perform the work "adequately and competently," or as economically, or because the work calls for the performance of new state functions. 1209 (1993-1994 Reg. 2d 644, 652 .) Again, in Delaney v. Lowery (1944) 25 Cal. opn., ante, at p. (See, e.g., County of Madera v. Gendron (1963) 59 Cal. Rptr. 1040.) 1018.) Listing for: Atlas Technical Consultants. (Maj. . As both United States Supreme Court precedent (FCC v. Beach Communications, Inc., supra, 508 U.S. at p. 315 [113 S.Ct. The rest are excluded from the collective bargaining because they are managers, supervisors, or employees who assist management develop employee compensation policies. With regard to the question before it, this court concluded: "Accordingly, starting with the presumption that the Legislature acted within its authority, we shall uphold the validity of [the statute at issue] if, by any reasonable construction, it can be said that the statute furthers the purposes of Proposition 103." II. FN 1. I recognize that the protracted litigation over Chapter 433 has by now probably defeated the Legislature's intent in this regard. PECG is a volunteer organization assisted by professional negotiators, consultants, attorneys, and Sacramento lobbyists and is not affiliated with any organization or union. As the dissent explained, "The trial court had determined the rights and obligations of the parties to this litigation under contracts entered into under the law preceding Chapter 433. at p. 696), or if the reasonableness of the enactment is fairly debatable (Lockard v. City of Los Angeles, supra, 33 Cal.2d at p. 462), the enactment must be upheld. Sess.) Unit 9 (Professional Engineers) MOU Analysis Format: HTML; August 25, 2022 - We reviewed the proposed memorandum of understanding for Bargaining Unit 9 (Professional Engineers). 4th 557] highway projects" in Caltrans's workload and is similarly subject to unavoidable delays and unanticipated expansion in scope. (Id. Article VII, like its predecessor, former article XXIV of the state Constitution, defines the state civil service as including "every officer and employee" of the state, with exceptions not pertinent here. Fund, supra, 30 Cal.2d at pp. (Accord, California Housing Finance Agency v. Patitucci (1978) 22 Cal. 1209 (1993-1994 Reg. 844-846.) 'Rather, it emanates from an implicit necessity for protecting the policy of the organic civil service mandate against dissolution and destruction.' Rptr. FN 7. January 12, 2022 Ted . It is the economic savings exception which is applicable here to find Chapter 433 constitutional on its face. As Caltrans readily concedes, it has always been responsible for project development of state highway projects. 6. It was precisely these findings of fact which the trial court utilized to undermine the legislative findings and to conclude that Chapter 433 was unconstitutional: "In Chapter 433 of the Statutes of 1993, the Legislature has sought to provide defendants with justifications under article VII to implement their administrative and management policies for contracting. [Citation.] 3d 208, 245 [149 Cal. 11 It simply allows the Director the discretion to contract out where such a move makes economic sense. The restriction does not arise from the express language of article VII. #CAStateEngineers. Please view theFingerprinting FAQsfor detailed information. UPDATED JANUARY 11, 2023 - NCEES is still seeking licensed mechanical engineers to participate in a professional activities and knowledge study (PAKS) for the PE Mechanical exams. 568-569; Collins v. Riley (1944) 24 Cal. 3d 171, 175 [148 Cal. As a matter of procedural history, the trial court was asked by Caltrans to consider Chapter 433 as changing the basis for its original injunction. [] For purposes of this section 'displacement' means layoff, demotion, involuntary transfer to a new class, or involuntary transfer to a new work location requiring the employee to change his or her place of residence in order to be able to continue in his or her job classification." 4th 1474, 1485 [35 Cal. (Colo. 1991) 809 P.2d 988, 992-998; Jack A. Parker & Assoc., Inc. v. State, etc. The current. In April 1990, the trial court enjoined defendant state Department of Transportation (Caltrans) from privately contracting for engineering and inspection services that state civil service employees had traditionally performed on state highway projects. Thus, merely characterizing work as "short-term" does not justify using private contractors to perform it. Rptr. 3.) 2d 93] (conc. omitted.) Cameron Knudson is president of Professional Engineers in California Government, representing 14,000 state engineers, architects, geologists, and related professionals. It is questionable whether a statute constitutionally could expressly bar the application of these safeguards. [] It would raise serious constitutional questions if we construed a statute to bar the safeguards against patronage developed in the case law, including the safeguard that the state be prepared to prove in a judicial forum that contracting out is warranted by considerations of economy or efficiency. App. 2d 288, 298 [73 P.2d 1221], italics added.) Responding to the trial court's injunction and orders, Caltrans took some steps to minimize and phase out private contracting during fiscal year 1993-1994. (Maj. fn. App. 2d 453, 461 [202 P.2d 38, 7 A.L.R.2d 990], wherein this court stated: " '[T]he rule is well settled that the legislative determination that the facts exist which make the law necessary, must not be set aside or disregarded by the courts, unless the legislative decision is clearly and palpably wrong and the error appears beyond reasonable doubt from facts or evidence which cannot be controverted, and of which the courts may properly take notice.' 15 Article VII does not involve "constitutionally protected rights," nor does Chapter 433 threaten such rights. (Williams, supra, 7 Cal.App.3d at p. 397, italics added.) The majority find Chapter 433's provisions "too far-reaching in scope" to qualify as permissible legislative experimentation under Professional Engineers, supra, 13 Cal. 2d 12, 906 P.2d 1112] (Amwest), quoting California Housing Finance Agency v. Elliott (1976) 17 Cal. It looks like your browser does not have JavaScript enabled. In Salazar, the trial court's injunction was based on "assumptions about the law" that changed when this court filed a new decision. 4th 582] traditionally performed where such services are withdrawn from state service or privatized on an experimental basis. (Gov. Amazing tells the story of the Maze reconstruction from the perspectives of all the main players in the drama: the now legendary contractor C.C. (Id. (See Burum v. State Compensation Ins. From 1991 to 1993, the court issued additional orders implementing its injunction. 225, 703 P.2d 1119] [finding unconstitutional an ordinance prohibiting fortune telling]; Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. v. FCC (1994) 512 U.S. 622, 666 [114 S. Ct. 2445, 2471, 129 L. Ed. endstream
endobj
376 0 obj
<>stream
[Citation. Read the Department's. Jason Falbo, P.Eng., M.B.A, Ph.D Candidate Jason is the chief technology officer at Mircom. of Alcoholic Bev. ), Finally, as we have explained, contrary to Caltrans's assumption, the civil service mandate does not preclude outright privatization of an existing state function. 1209 (1993-1994 Reg. It was recognized, for example, that the alternative of placing the entire exemption power with the Legislature would [subject] the legislators to unduly severe pressures to carve out various exceptions to the application of civil service laws and that much strain on the integrity and efficacy of the civil service system could result." fn. ", Under the rule of Lockard and Stevenson, the trial court's prior factual findings when made could not properly be the basis upon which to find erroneous the legislative conclusions set forth to support Chapter 433. 3d 258, 282 [96 Cal. [Citations.]' 374 0 obj
<>stream
" (Amwest, supra, 11 Cal.4th at p. 1253, italics added. Easy 1-Click Apply (DUNHILL PROFESSIONAL SEARCH & GOVERNMENT SOLUTIONS) System Engineer Lead - Remote job in Fairfax at Dunhill Professional Search job in Dallas, TX. As the majority opinion stated, " the trial court ignored legislative findings justifying the maintenance of Caltrans's staff at levels that will not necessitate costly short-term hirings and layoffs due to workload fluctuations resulting from the volatility of funding sources." FN 14. This is consistent with article VII, as interpreted by Riley and its progeny. Const., former art. v. State Bd. San Jacinto College Faculty Association v. Mt. 1566.) 3d 531, 547-549 [174 Cal. v. State Bd. In light of our conclusion that Chapter 433 affords no basis for modification of the trial court's injunction, we need not reach plaintiffs' further argument that Chapter 433 is invalid as a violation of separation of power principles. Given the pressing demands upon California to meet its growing transportation needs and the funding and safety concerns that support timely project delivery, it behooves this court to uphold legislative experimentation to the maximum extent consistent with article VII of our state Constitution. 245. (Tobe v. City of Santa Ana (1995) 9 Cal. As there described by the Court of Appeal, "[t]his legislation arose from a legislative determination that '[p]ublic sources of revenues to provide an efficient transportation system have not kept pace with California's growing transportation needs, and alternative funding sources should be developed to augment or supplement available public sources of revenue.' The Court of Appeal majority reversed the judgment and remanded the matter to the trial court with directions to dissolve its 1990 injunction. However, "a reviewing court may, in appropriate circumstances, and consistently with the separation of powers doctrine, [15 Cal. 4th 598] (1943) 22 Cal. 603-605. Code Regs., tit. Website. In any event, Caltrans fails to indicate whether these studies were [15 Cal. 4th 765, 780 [35 Cal. As plaintiffs observe, " there is no evidence in the record to support [15 Cal. [15 Cal. Please note that this does not mean a license or certification must be issued, but simply that the process will be expedited. In that case, the Legislature had authorized Caltrans to contract with private development firms to construct and operate tollways under state lease, in order to secure needed transportation systems unobtainable through public financing arrangements. The trial court clearly engaged in its own independent factual analysis to conclude that the findings expressed by the Legislature in support of Chapter 433 were unsubstantiated and wrong; hence, the legislation is unconstitutional. 2d 93, 95 A.L.R.2d 1347]. 180. those who attack the statute, to prove they do not. Daniel E. Lungren, Attorney General, Floyd D. Shimomura, Assistant Attorney General, Linda A. Cabatic and Daniel G. Stone, Deputy Attorneys General, William M. McMillan, Richard W. Bower, O. J. Solander, Stephanie G. Sakai, Irell & Manella, Gregory R. Smith, Joanna Moore and David Z. Moss for Defendants and Appellants. Recall Election. 3. Caltrans submitted no such study, and the available evidence (involving pre-1993 fiscal years) supported a contrary finding. [FtdI6B'[` M5qGw$u2J^tB}cs #""p hs@4p5@\]mf/;\=\zk/iJC3a3M$7E= t6l?tX-Fi'~JFJIo#sEiQ:WqO~;Km?EK~\%~i,DLzau[HN][4]h=$[RsW=XTjKuu/>_7#_%s San Jacinto Community College District, Paul Sanchez v. Orange County Employees Association, Panama-Buena Vista Teachers Association v. Panama-Buena Vista Unified School District, Unite Summit, CTA/NEA v. Summit Public Schools, Registered Nurses Professional Association & Service Employees International Union Local 521 v. County of Santa Clara, Oakland Education Association v. Oakland Unified School District, Pittsburg Education Association, CTA/NEA v. Pittsburg Unified School District, Gavin English v. Inglewood Unified School District, David Lisker v. San Francisco Community College District, Mammoth Lakes Police Officers Association v. Town of Mammoth Lakes, Alameda Probation Peace Officers Association v. County of Alameda (Probation Department), Compton Firefighters, IAFF Local 2216 v. City of Compton, Daniel Boreen v. City & County of San Francisco, United Public Employees, Inc. v. Sacramento County Superior Court, Jorge Robles v. State of California (Department of Corrections & Rehabilitation), Long Beach Association of Engineering Employees v. City of Long Beach, Service Employees International Union Local 1000 v. State of California (Department of Motor Vehicles), Cerritos College Faculty Federation, AFT Local 6215 v. Cerritos Community College District, Sacramento City Teachers Association v. Sacramento City Unified School District, United Teachers Los Angeles v. Los Angeles Unified School District, Operating Engineers Local 3 v. Santa Clara County Superior Court, Lillian Edith Grant v. Inglewood Unified School District, Sacramento City Teachers Association. The existence of this statute is not relevant to a determination as to the facial validity of Chapter 433. ), [3c] Does Chapter 433 contain factually supported findings that would excuse noncompliance with the civil service mandate? In my view, Caltrans should not have to prove the economies of any particular contract in advance of the mandated study if the whole purpose of the study is to ascertain just such information. Rptr. Although the legislation at issue in Professional Engineers differs from Chapter 433 insofar as it involved no expenditure of state funds, the majority recognize that article VII would permit experimentation "despite the use of state funding." I see no legitimate basis for such an approach, which intrudes upon the legislative process in outright disregard of the separation of powers. Founded 1962. (a)(4).) of Labor & Industry (1993) 154 Pa.Commw. Rptr. FN 4. Judicial notice of prior factual determinations of the superior court does not satisfy plaintiffs' burden inasmuch as circumstances may have changed in the interim. 4th 568] Caltrans' bare claim that the use of contracts 'results in faster and less expensive service delivery.' The majority have not shown that the Legislature was clearly or palpably wrong in determining that Chapter 433's provisions for additional flexibility in contracting will promote efficiency and economy in state government. fn. PECG has headquarters in Sacramento and maintains satellite offices in San Francisco and Glendale. Const. One of PECGs goals is to promote the highest standards of professional practice. (Gov. endstream
endobj
378 0 obj
<>stream
Thus, section 14130, subdivision (d), purports to relieve Caltrans from its obligations (1) to use state employees to perform engineering and related services "to the maximum extent required to meet the goals of this article," and (2) "to staff at an internal level that matches its ability to assimilate and productively use new staff." "); People v. Globe Grain & Mill Co., supra, 211 Cal. (See People v. Globe Grain & Mill Co. (1930) 211 Cal. Significantly, the same legislative report frankly acknowledged that, because the proposed legislation purported to expand by statute the authority for private contracting, "questions" had been raised regarding its constitutionality, and it was "unclear" what effect, if any, the proposed legislation would have on this contracting. Code, 4525 et seq. Caltrans failed to appeal those orders. Section 14130, subdivision (a)(4), recites that private contracting has helped "accelerate[] nearly one billion dollars ($1,000,000,000) worth of construction projects on the state highway system. The applicant is responsible for complying with the current requirements of theProfessional Engineers Actand theBoard Rules and Regulations. Refugees pursuant to section 1157 of title 8 of the United States Code; Those granted asylum by the Secretary of Homeland Security or the Attorney General of the United States pursuant to section 1158 of title 8 of the United States Code; or. Yet, as the majority also notes, the section does appear to "find" private contracting necessary to permit Caltrans to perform its project delivery in a timely manner. In this regard, the prohibition against contracting out is not a direct constitutional expression: nowhere does article VII expressly say what Riley and its progeny say it means. 2d 599] (Professional Engineers), the Court of Appeal held that, on an experimental basis, the state might properly release a former function in favor of "privatization" without offending civil service principles. ", The dissent reviewed the history of the proceedings in this case and observed that, "[u]nable to make headway with the judicial branch's tiresome requirement that Caltrans produce evidence that contracting out was warranted as cheaper or more efficient, Caltrans sought a sanction from the Legislature for its practice of contracting out. Respondents' petition for a rehearing was denied July 16, 1997. 9 (Gov. [Citation.] Evidence Code section 452, subdivision (d) permits judicial notice to be taken of records of "any court of this state.". (Lockard v. City of Los Angeles (1949) 33 Cal. 817, 621 P.2d 856].) As this court recently explained, "Although the language of California Constitution article III, section 3, may suggest a sharp demarcation between the operations of the three branches of government, California decisions long have recognized that, in reality, the separation of powers doctrine ' "does not mean that the three departments of our government are not in many respects mutually dependent" ' [citation], or that the actions of one branch may not significantly affect those of another branch. As Caltrans graphically puts it, "[t]he incoherent, unworkable, and potentially crippling tests which encrust and distort article VII are not even hinted at by its language." Morales, et al., 40 Cal.4th 1016 (2007), the union representing government engineers in California sued the State of California arguing that Government Code section 4529.12's "fair, competitive selection process" language mandated competitive bidding of professional services and abrogated California's pre-Proposition 35 QBS process. 2023 National Society of Professional Engineers | 1420 King St . & Hy. [15 Cal. (Ibid. (Maj. By enacting article VII, the electorate sought to obtain fiscal responsibility in government. ). v. D.O.H. "This is entirely consistent with the civil service mandate, a key purpose of which is to encourage efficiency and economy in state government. (f), p. At issue was whether a subsequently enacted statute furthered the purposes of the act. Unless a statute's unconstitutionality " 'clearly, positively, and unmistakably appears' " (Calfarm Ins. In the majority's view, "The burden is not on Caltrans to prove the facts support the legislative determination but on plaintiffs, i.e. Thus, as previously explained (ante, at pp. 13,000. Fax (916) 322-0765 . 4th 552] are inapplicable to professional and technical service contracts made under section 14130 et seq. (c), operative until Jan. 1, 1998, 14130.1, 14130.2. Myers; Caltrans Director Will Kempton and his Caltrans engineers; the Arizona steel fabricator whose company built the steel girders; the firefighter who responded to the accident; and the reporters who covered the story. In examining Chapter 433, it must be presumed the Legislature intended its act to be valid and to fall within the scope of its constitutional powers. 4th 593] Cal.Rptr.2d 837, 913 P.2d 1046].) 135.) as amended July 14, 1993.) The Court of Appeal in Stockburger, supra, 21 Cal.App.2d at page 167, had questioned the relevance of cost savings, but CSEA overruled that decision in light of the ballot argument's emphasis on "efficiency and economy." I conclude that the trial court erred in rejecting the factual findings of the Legislature, and that neither the trial court nor this court may reject such findings except under very limited circumstances not present here. Additional Information for Comity Applicants:
This is elementary. 397-400 [permitting state to hire private insurance carriers to administer state Medi-Cal program].) 568.) ), The trial court in the instant case was aware of the restrictions placed upon its power to make factual determinations regarding statutes. 4th 550] promote efficiency and economy' " in state government, and "to eliminate the 'spoils system' of political patronage." ), The majority note that the trial court's 1990 injunction has become final, and that Caltrans has never challenged the trial court's earlier findings and conclusions.