SS Francisco Lindor (84 overall)6. Meanwhile, center fielder Kevin Kiermaier is propped up by his 99 fielding and 99 reaction ratings. C Salvador Perez (88 overall)2. There's no arguing that Jacob deGrom. A lot of this is subjective, but that's just flat-out wrong. While on the surface you see just simple names, positions, numbers, teams, and ratings, there is more to it within each player page. Instant Reaction: No one on the Oakland Athletics' MLB roster has an "A" potential grade. Mitch Garver (Texas Rangers) 85 Mike Trout (Los Angeles Angels) - 99 1B Trey Mancini (76 overall)4. Yasmani Grandal (Chicago White Sox) - 91 C Austin Nola (81 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SP MacKenzie Gore (68 overall, "A" potential), Overrated: 2B Jake Cronenworth (85 overall). 5=. 3B Charlie Culberson (75 overall)10. SP Jon Gray (77 overall)7. 2=. SP Logan Webb (87 overall)3. Doubts were cast over Mike Trouts fantasy draft placing ahead of this season, with some managers choosing to select Fernando Tatis Jr or Mookie Betts ahead of him. 2B Jorge Mateo (77 overall)7. Marcus Semien (Texas Rangers) 97 2. SP Patrick Corbin (83 overall)7. SP Michael Lorenzen (76 overall)10. 2B Jose Altuve (92 overall)2. 2. 5=. SP Lucas Giolito (87 overall)5. At the same time, if he's not an "A" potential player, no one is. Head-Scratcher: Even before his brilliant start to the 2021 season, Musgrove seemed like an easy choice to be ranked ahead of Chris Paddack (81 overall) based on what he's done in Pittsburgh the past few seasons. Trademarks and brands are the property of their respective 3B Rafael Devers (86 overall)5. SP Freddy Peralta (89 overall)4. Martinez (87 overall)4. Michael Baumann is now SP for the Orioles. RP Sean Doolittle (75 overall)10. Trout, de Grom lead MLB The Show 21 player ratings. SP Blake Snell (84 overall)8. Instant Reaction: Does Dylan Moore work at Sony? 3B Brian Anderson (80 overall)4. As for the Dodgers: how can you not be tempted by Kershaw (93), Walker Buehler (92), Trevor Bauer (90) and Julio Urias (90)? C Yasmani Grandal (91 overall)3. Meanwhile, MLB.com (No. RP Collin McHugh (84 overall)8. C Willson Contreras (85 overall)3. RP Will Harris (80 overall)9. LF Eloy Jimenez (82 overall)8. Fernando Tatis Jr (San Diego Padres) - 95 LF Joey Gallo (89 overall)4. Here's a quick rundown of what you'll find on each team page: My gamer tag is JReuter10988 on PlayStation network. SP Justin Verlander (88 overall)5. RP Andrew Chafin (81 overall)4. This is a discussion on Accurate Attribute Spreadsheets within the MLB The Show Rosters forums. On top of that, the community marketplace in Diamond Dynasty to buy and sell cards is integrated between platforms, so that economy is thriving more than ever. 1. RP J.B. Wendelken (80 overall)9. This whole roster needs a total redo. (PSN|XBL|NSW) Dashboard 3B Eduardo Escobar (79 overall)8. Seth Lugo (New York Mets) - 85 SP Mike Minor (78 overall)8. 3B Josh Donaldson (85 overall)6. If you're looking for the absolute top players in MLB The Show 21, the real gems exist on the game's massive Legends Roster. SS Oneil Cruz (71 overall)10. 2B Jorge Polanco (85 overall)5. Betts joins Arenado in being one point short of perfection bettered only by DeGrom on the pitching side, and Trout on the batting front. The ratings were based on "a 3-year performance average" according to the group. Ryan Pressly (Houston Astros) 89 3B Alex Bregman (92 overall)2. 3B Jeimer Candelario (78 overall)3. 1B Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (96 overall)2. SS Tim Anderson (83 overall)7. SP Tyler Anderson (72 overall)7. Jacob deGrom and Mike Trout top the list of MLB The Show 21 player ratings. SP Lance Lynn (87 overall)6. 1B Josh Bell (78 overall)6. RP Chris Martin (82 overall)9. SP Aaron Nola (92 overall)2. Freeman holds firm on top with a huge 90 overall, while Voit gatecrashes the first-base party after creaming 22 homers in just 56 games last year. Aaron Nola, Anthony Rendon, and DJ LeMahieu all lost their Diamond status by having their ratings dip below 85 OVR with this roster update. 5=. MLB The Show 21 dropped the latest biweekly roster update, and this one saw six different players make the jump to Diamond status. SP Aaron Civale (82 overall)5. SP Lance McCullers Jr. (84 overall)10. The 29-year-old utility infielder hit .181 with a 71 OPS+ and 0.9 WAR last season, yet he's tied for the third-highest-rated player on the Seattle roster. With all the amazing players all over the world, I am shocked that the plat is only at 0.4%. RP Taylor Rogers (84 overall)6. CF Trent Grisham (80 overall)10. 3. SP Corbin Burnes (80 overall)8. Head-Scratcher: It's easy to love McNeil, but is there really anyone who thinks he's a better player than Lindor? SP John Means (75 overall)5. Head-Scratcher: Listing Segura, Didi Gregorius and Scott Kingery all as shortstop just feels lazy, and that's especially true of Kingery. 5. The Show is where you talk about MLB The Show! Clayton Kershaw (Los Angeles Dodgers) - 95 3B Yoan Moncada (81 overall)10. Official MLB The Show 21 Team Rankings All of these are pretty self-explanatory. That feels about right for a team that stripped the roster to the studs this offseason and still might not be done dealing after sending Sean Manaea to the San Diego Padres over the weekend. CF Kevin Kiermaier (83 overall)4. Generic filters. C Manny Pina (79 overall)10. 1. SS Corey Seager (80 overall)5. RF Mookie Betts (98 overall)2. SP Casey Mize (76 overall), Franchise Mode Target: 1B Spencer Torkelson (74 overall, "A" potential), Underrated:RF Robbie Grossman (72 overall). RP Tyler Duffey (83 overall)7. It looks like Stott could start the season at third base, but he's the shortstop of the not-so-distant future. When it comes to team ratings in MLB The Show 21, things went a little differently this year as each team was given an overall ranking and then ranked based on various categories. RP Edwin Diaz (82 overall)9. SP Patrick Corbin (77 overall)7. RP Jake McGee (76 overall), Franchise Mode Target: C Joey Bart (73 overall, "A" potential), Underrated: 2B Tommy La Stella (75 overall). MLB The Show 22; MLB The Show 21; MLB The Show 20; MLB The Show 19 . Max Scherzer (New York Mets) 97 SP Ryan Yarbrough (82 overall)5. RF Teoscar Hernandez (86 overall)8. 1. 2B Dylan Moore (81 overall)7. Best Ratings: 99 Velocity, 98 Hits per 9 Innings, 89 Stamina The highest rated pitcher in the game and thought of as the best pitcher in baseball - when healthy - Jacob deGrom is formidable on the mound, but also at the plate even though he might not hold the two-way status of Shohei Ohtani. Instant Reaction: Slapping an 81 overall on Michael Kopech when he has never pitched more than 69.1 innings in a season and is making the move from swingman to full-time member of the rotation is bold, but there's no question he has the stuff to be an elite starter. RP Oliver Perez (80 overall)6. 2B Tony Kemp (76 overall)6. 3B Evan Longoria (77 overall)8. MLB The Show fans can use the Diamond Dynasty Database website tool to find their ideal player, search for players who fit within their desired criteria, and help determine where they'll need to commit their hours to build the best team. 3. Instant Reaction: Kirby Yates was arguably baseball's best closer as recently as 2019. 3B Rafael Devers (81 overall)7. 2=. Clayton Kershaw (Los Angeles Dodgers) 93 SP Gerrit Cole (94 overall)3. RF Nicholas Castellanos (79 overall)7. 2B Ozzie Albies (93 overall)4. SP Alek Manoah (87 overall)7. 2. At the same time, Bobby Witt Jr. is undoubtedly already one of the 10 best players on the Royals roster, and he could challenge for the No. SP Zach Davies (81 overall)8. 3B Alec Bohm (78 overall)9. Aaron Judge (RF, New York Yankees) 96 His 66 overall rating is also a bit harsh for a player who is MLB-ready. RF Whit Merrifield (78 overall)8. Milwaukee are well stocked too, with 94-rated Burnes backed up by Brandon Woodruff (92) and Freddy Peralta (89). SP Chris Sale (93 overall)3. SP Andrew Heaney (79 overall)8. content may be reproduced without permission. SP Chris Sale (93 overall)2. 1. SP Jose Berrios (81 overall)9. 1. SP Corey Kluber (83 overall)7. SP Yu Darvish (85 overall)5. RP Lou Trivino (73 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SS Robert Puason (71 overall, "A" potential). SP Eduardo Rodriguez (80 overall)5. Freddie Freeman (Atlanta Braves) - 95 2. So, unlike in previous guides, were now doing the same. As players use their Ballplayer in Diamond Dynasty and Road to the Show, that will improve their attributes and unlock better loadouts and equipment to give that player a higher rating. LF Austin Meadows (81 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SP Shane Baz (74 overall, "A" potential). Follow @lineups . Max Scherzer (Washington Nationals) - 94. RP Blake Treinen (84 overall), Franchise Mode Target: 2B Michael Busch (70 overall, "A" potential), Overrated: CF Cody Bellinger (81 overall), Underrated: RP Tyler Anderson (69 overall). Corbin Burnes SP | Brewers . SP Miles Mikolas (81 overall), Franchise Mode Target: RF Dylan Carlson (70 overall, "A" potential). Head-Scratcher: The developers seem awfully high on shortstop prospect Terrin Vavra (67 overall, "A" potential), who was acquired from the Colorado Rockies in last year's Mychal Givens deal. 1. 1B Max Muncy (85 overall)9. SP Corbin Burnes (94 overall)2. 2B Kolten Wong (83 overall)9. Mike Trout CF | Angels . SP Max Fried (84 overall)8. 4 guy heading into spring training and to start the year. RF Bryce Harper (90 overall)4. Ozzie Albies (Atlanta Braves) 91 When you purchase Get the best gaming deals, reviews, product advice, competitions, unmissable gaming news and more! Copyright 1998-2019 Operation Sports LLC | Core, MLB The Show 23 Diamond Dynasty Feature Premiere Analysis, What's New With eFootball 2023 and the V2.4 Update, https://docs.google.com/spreadsheetsit?usp=sharing. LF Jesse Winker (83 overall)3. SP Luis Severino (81 overall)10. RF Sam Hilliard (83 overall), Franchise Mode Target: 1B Michael Toglia (63 overall, "A" potential), Overrated: 2B Garrett Hampson (76 overall). With four starting pitchers ranked 84 overall or higher, this might be the best starting rotation the team has had since the early 1990s, when they won back-to-back World Series titles. 1. SS Trea Turner (94 overall)2. C Yasmani Grandal (93 overall)2. 2. 3B Patrick Wisdom (83 overall)6. (PSN|XBL|NSW) Dashboard Inventory Squads Community Market Leaderboards Roster Updates Shop APIs FAQs MLB The Show 22 MLB The Show 21 MLB The Show 20 MLB The Show 19 Hi, Guest! 2 Aaron Judge. 1B Rhys Hoskins (80 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SS Bryson Stott (71 overall, "B" potential), Underrated: LF Matt Vierling (65 overall). 2B Cesar Hernandez (81 overall)5. SP Zack Greinke (90 overall)4. SS Francisco Lindor (88 overall)4. It's a big stretch to give him "A" potential at this point. 4. CF Bryan Reynolds (84 overall)2. Bo Bichette (Toronto Blue Jays) 87 Martinez (87 overall)3. Just sayin' Top 10 Players1. Some players are correct, while others are not. One of the biggest changes in each is players that get their ratings boosted up to 85 or higher, and that makes them Diamond tier rather than Gold, Silver, Bronze, or Common. Both guys have yet to reach 120 games in the big leagues, so the 2022 season will be a big one in determining their future roles on the team. 2B Mike Moustakas (82 overall)5. 4=. LF Giancarlo Stanton (87 overall)5. THESHOW.COM. RF Adam Duvall (78 overall)8. SP Framber Valdez (83 overall)9. 1. RP Josh Hader (85 overall)6. Joey Gallo (LF, New York Yankees) 89, Unlike real-life, MLB The Show 22 splits outfielders across the RF, CF, and LF categories so weve expanded this to a top ten rather than a fab five. SP Kyle Gibson (74 overall), Franchise Mode Target: CF Bubba Thompson (68 overall, "A" potential), Overrated: SS Charlie Culberson (74 overall), Underrated: LF Willie Calhoun (69 overall). CF Lorenzo Cain (79 overall)9. Anthony Rendon (Los Angeles Angels) 86 1B Freddie Freeman (93 overall)3. Juan Soto (Washington Nationals) - 95 4=. Nolan Arenado (St Louis Cardinals) - 98 Major League and Minor League Baseball trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of Major League Baseball. Those were among the questions we set out to answer while perusing the roster for all 30 teams in the latest video game offering from San Diego Studio. View Top 100 MLB The Show 22 Player Ratings! SP Michael Kopech (81 overall)9. 2B Jose Altuve (88 overall)5. 2022 Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC. CF Victor Robles (81 overall)8. C Christian Vazquez (85 overall)4. Just two players come in at 99 overall in MLB The Show 21 player ratings at the game's launch and both are highly deserving. LF Christian Yelich (85 overall)7. 1B Joey Votto (83 overall)2. 1. All rankings are based on game. 1. 2B Jake Cronenworth (85 overall)8. SP Spencer Turnbull (75 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SP Casey Mize (69 overall, "A" potential). Tyler ONeill (LF, St Louis Cardinals) 90 Giancarlo Stanton (New York Yankees) - 92 These players are spread across three Legends themed teams (Mid-Century Groundbreakers, Expansion Era Boomers, Long Ball Beasts) with a handful also tucked away in the Free Agents roster. SP Sean Manaea (80 overall)8. CF Ketel Marte (83 overall)3. The reason Chad Green didnt nab that closers job in New York to kick off the 2021 season? 1B Pete Alonso (84 overall)5. C Carson Kelly (76 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SP Blake Walston (68 overall, "A" potential), Overrated: Madison Bumgarner (80 overall). CP Taylor Rogers (86 overall)4. CP Jose Leclerc (81 overall)3. Instant Reaction: Staying extremely high on Jasson Dominguez (72 overall, "A" potential) and not pumping up Anthony Volpe (65 overall, "A" potential) feels like one of the bigger misses on the prospect side of things, especially considering all of the hype Volpe has going into the year. C Austin Hedges (78 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SS Brayan Rocchio (68 overall, "A" potential), Underrated: RP Emmanuel Clase (66 overall). 1. SP Dallas Keuchel (82 overall)9. 2B Brandon Lowe (90 overall)2. SP Walker Buehler (89 overall)6. 1=. Freddie Freeman (Atlanta Braves) - 95 2B Cesar Hernandez (81 overall)9. 5=. Kohei Arihara had a 6.64 ERA in 10 starts last year before he was removed from the 40-man roster, yet he's the team's third-best starter? C Yadier Molina (85 overall)9. LF Kyle Schwarber (84 overall)9. Trea Turner (Los Angeles Dodgers) 94 Younger players like Buehler and Bieber will need to maintain their impressive. The Show is shaking up everything from top to bottom. 1B Matt Olson (83 overall)5. SP Framber Valdez (80 overall), Franchise Mode Target: C Korey Lee (75 overall, "A" potential). SS Adalberto Mondesi (86 overall)3. CP Will Smith (82 overall)10. SP Austin Gomber (74 overall)10. SS Wander Franco (81 overall)9. RP Matt Barnes (83 overall)9. SP Trevor Rogers (84 overall)5. Of the three, Hampson might be the one who fits best in a utility role. SS Amed Rosario (79 overall)9. 1. CF Mike Trout (99 overall)2. Head-Scratcher: Why is Locastro a second baseman? 1B C.J. 4=. Top 10 Players # Player OVR; 1. We've got everything you need to know about the best teams, main roster players, and details on MLB The Show 21 ratings for Diamond Dynasty. LF Giancarlo Stanton (92 overall)5. The Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, Inc., as applicable. CF Victor Reyes (75 overall)10. 2B Jazz Chisholm (84 overall)3. Head-Scratcher: Cloney went 12-1 with a 2.21 ERA in 14 starts between rookie ball and Single-A in 2018, but he was old for his level and lacked swing-and-miss stuff. Instant Reaction: Trevor Story has a more well-rounded skill set than Rafael Devers and Xander Bogaerts, who don't provide much in the way of base-running value and are below-average defenders at their positions, so it makes sense that he'd have a higher overall rating. Instant Reaction: There were plenty of choices for most underrated player on the Giants roster, with Alex Cobb (75 overall), Camilo Doval (73 overall), Tommy La Stella (72 overall), Steven Duggar (70 overall) and Joc Pederson (70 overall) also seemingly a few ticks below where they should be ranked. He has excellent arm strength but typically posts below-average marks as a receiver. 4. 2B Dylan Moore (81 overall)5. That clearly speaks to a team on the rise looking to make a move up the AL Central standings. Matt Muncy (Los Angeles Dodgers) 91 4. Mike Trout (CF, Los Angeles Angels) 99 4. 2B Wilmer Flores (77 overall)7. RF Juan Soto (91 overall)2. SP Sonny Gray (87 overall)3. SP Trevor Bauer (93 overall)4. There are only 11 starting pitchers in the game with at least a 90 overall rating. CP Kirby Yates (86 overall)7. Yasmani Grandal (Chicago White Sox) 93 Christian Yelich (Minnesota Brewers) - 96 Liam Hendriks (Chicago White Sox) - 93 SP Sandy Alcantara (77 overall)9. 1. Since there is going to be a ratings preview stream, here is what I've gathered for some notable players going into 20. Please Wait. HITTING Power vs RHP. CF Ronald Acuna Jr. (94 overall)3. 1. That stats is even more staggering when you learn that he crashed 21 homers the year beforehand - in more than double the time, at 118 games. He was named Reliever of the Year in both 2020 and 2021, dishing up 113 strikeouts on his way to 38 saves and an 8-3 record last time out. SP Cole Irvin (74 overall)8. MLB The Show 21 player ratings: the top five players . 1B Brandon Belt (78 overall)6. SP Tyler Mahle (82 overall)4. RF Hunter Renfroe (84 overall)8. MLB The Show: Player Database Homeplate / Players View Column Definitions True Overall - This rating applies a weighted formula to each position, taking into account all player attributes weighted independently, then takes the cap off of the maximum 99 overall rating to provide a True reflection of a player's overall rating Table of Contents Latest - Six new Diamonds in. SP Zac Gallen (82 overall)3. All six of these names also made last years top ten, making it a position that rewards consistency. RP Tyler Clippard (75 overall)9. 1. Jose Abreu (Chicago White Sox) - 88 4.. 1. 5=. 4=. SP Jon Gray (77 overall)6. The Show 21 has its own fair share of young guns in the game. CP Giovanny Gallegos (89 overall)5. 1B Ryan Mountcastle (80 overall) 5. That full tool box should easily make him a 90-overall player. The Cardinals veteran does take a small ratings hit, however, dropping from 98 in MLB The Show 21 to a slightly more modest (yet still imperious) 95. SP Sandy Alcantara (84 overall)2. 1. Chris Sale (Boston Red Sox) 93. Complete MLB The Show 22 player ratings for Dodgers roster Starting pitchers: Clayton Kershaw (93), Walker Buehler (92), Julio Urias (90), Tony Gonsolin (81), Danny Duffy (80), Dustin May. NY 10036. Instant Reaction: I completely understand not wanting to overrate unproven prospects who have not yet reached the majors. 1. Instant Reaction: Respect where it's due, but Clayton Kershaw is the third-best pitcher on the Dodgers these days. Still, in MLB The Show, any player rated 85 or higher is considered the absolute cream of the crop. 5. CF Cedric Mullins (86 overall)2. SP Sonny Gray (81 overall)6. SP Ranger Suarez (87 overall)8. Thought I might share what I've made and been using for quite a few years now. CF Byron Buxton (88 overall)3. 1. The old lady, Juventus, is returning, there's the debut of the Women's Super League . Byron Buxton (CF, Minnesota Twins) 91 CP Matt Barnes (77 overall), Franchise Mode Target: CF Gilberto Jimenez (64 overall, "A" potential), Overrated: 2B Enrique Hernandez (82 overall), Underrated: 3B Rafael Devers (81 overall). LF David Dahl (75 overall)7. (All the Streets Of Rage games, actually.) The Mets are surely cheating with two pitchers rated 97 or higher and Chris Bassitt (83) and Taijuan Walker (80) make their rotation one of the games best. Kirby Yates (Toronto Blue Jays) - 88 He saw the bulk of his playing time in center field last year and his natural position is second base. 1. Scarily, Guerrero earns the honour of the games best first baseman at the age of just 23 and his A-rated potential should see you good for 15 years of power hitting if you use the Blue Jays in franchise mode. CP Craig Kimbrel (78 overall)10. Add a filter. RP Wander Suero (79 overall), Franchise Mode Target: 3B Carter Kieboom (68 overall, "A" potential). Season: . LF Robert Neustrom (74 overall), Franchise Mode Target: C Adley Rutschman (74 overall, "A" potential), Underrated: RF Anthony Santander (72 overall). SP Pablo Lopez (82 overall)7. 3B Ke'Bryan Hayes (81 overall)4. 3B Eugenio Suarez (80 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SS Noelvi Marte (72 overall, "A" potential), Underrated: SS J.P. Crawford (76 overall). MLB The Show 22; MLB The Show 21; MLB The Show 20; MLB The Show 19; Hi, Guest! For which four starters and the four bullpen players I have chosen I have used ESPN's Depth Chart under each team. C Manny Pina (83 overall), Franchise Mode Target: CF Michael Harris II (59 overall, "A" potential). Instant Reaction: Is Nico Hoerner really that much better than Nick Madrigal? RF Mitch Haniger (81 overall)6. LF Randy Arozarena (87 overall)3. 4. 2B Enrique Hernandez (82 overall)6. SP Zach Thompson (79 overall)6. 4=. Please Wait. RF Michael Conforto (87 overall)5. Cron (77 overall)5. MLB Players . 2B David Fletcher (87 overall)4. Join. RP Archie Bradley (77 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SS Bryson Stott (71 overall, "A" potential), Overrated: LF Andrew McCutchen (83 overall). Why not bump his rating down 10-15 points and make him a non-factor in this year's game, rather than the best player on the Seattle roster? Manny Machado (St Diego Padres) - 95 3B Austin Riley (83 overall)9. It allows you the opportunity to purchase duplicates on the Community Market of a card before it jumps to Diamond status, and selling them after the change can be very lucrative. C Mitch Garver (78 overall), Franchise Mode Target: SP Jordan Balazovic (69 overall, "A" potential), Overrated: 3B Josh Donaldson (90 overall), Underrated: SP Michael Pineda (75 overall).